Rom Eng
RSS feed
Home / Opinions & Comments / Can Moldova join the East and the West simultaneously? Nicu Popescu, Valentin Krilov, Valeriu Murasvschi.
Can Moldova join the East and the West simultaneously? Nicu Popescu, Valentin Krilov, Valeriu Murasvschi.
Print version

Analytical Bulletin by the Committee for Freedom of the Press. email: phone / fax: + 373  22  21 41 55

President Vladimir Voronin said recently that Moldova's pro-European foreign policy orientation and its simultaneous participation in „integration projects” within the Commonwealth of Independent States is „logical and consistent.” Mr. Voronin made the statement during a reception on January 29 for diplomats residing in Moldova and participants at an informal meeting of foreign affairs ministers from countries participating in the South-East European Cooperation Process.

„We are often criticized for being „omnivorous” in our foreign policy, for moving toward the European Union without turning our backs on our partners in the East. I am talking about our relatively interested activism in pursuing integration projects within the CIS, and our attachment to a strategic partnership with the Russian Federation. We, however, believe that our position is logical enough and consistent enough,” declared President Voronin.

Voronin added that Moldova does not perceive European integration as a „friendship against someone, as a caricature attempt at isolating ourselves from Russia and CIS countries with a new artificial iron curtain. We perceive our European option as a form of realizing the values of openness and universality, as an ability to find different fields for establishing durable and viable partnerships.”

At the same time, President Voronin admitted that no precedents for such partnerships exist and hinted at the fact the CIS countries remain unable to overlook „narrow state egoism.”

According to Mr. Voronin, during its presidency of the CIS, Moldova will push an agenda that is „not formal at all,” and applicable to „both the EU and the CIS.”


Nicu Popescu: There should be a difference between integration and cooperation

Nicu Popescu, a political analyst and researcher with the London-based European Council for Foreign Relations, says that a distinction needs to be made between integration and cooperation. „European integration is absolutely compatible with very good relations with Russia, Ukraine, or Armenia, but is incompatible with integration in the CIS. European integration implies European values and legislation – the CIS is very different from the EU in this sense. Russian standards, for example, when it comes to democracy or the economy, are different from European standards, for which reason Moldova cannot simultaneously integrate in both directions,” argues Mr. Popescu.

In the expert's opinion, some of the advantages of cooperating with the CIS include the fact that this organization „has been a safety belt during the disintegration of the Soviet Union, but it no longer plays that historical role and can no longer play a positive role in the future of Moldova as an independent state that wishes to become European.”

With regards to a comparative ability of the CIS and the EU to avoid the global economic crisis, Mr. Popescu avers that the former cannot be compared to the latter because „the CIS is only a club of states and, broadly speaking, does not have an instrument to overcome the crisis. The EU, however, is a completely different actor, with a substantial budget that is used to help member states build roads, pay agricultural subsidies, develop energy infrastructure and, therefore, use such instruments and other abilities to already help member-states who are in crisis.”

Nicu Popescu concludes that, if Moldova exited the CIS, it would not lose too much because „the real ties of cooperation Chisinau has with the East are not established through the CIS, but bilaterally with Russia, Ukraine, Belarus, and so on. The CIS only has symbolic value.”

Valentin Krilov: Membership in the EU is not prohibited by the CIS status, but there is the security problem

Valentin Krilov, executive secretary of the Patria-Rodina Socialist Party agrees with President Voronin's idea that Moldova can cooperate with the EU and the CIS simultaneously. „Membership in the EU is not prohibited by the CIS status, but there is the security problem. Most EU states are members of NATO, and European security norms are actually NATO norms,” believes Mr. Krilov. In Mr. Krilov's opinion, cooperation within the CIS would bring Moldova a series of socio-economic advantages, while EU cooperation would help the country achieve „real democracy.”

„With regards to the current economic crisis, the CIS is more attractive for Moldova because Russia, Kazakhstan, and Belarus, for example, are strong economically. These governments simply need to coordinate their actions and cooperate more actively to overcome the effects of the crisis. The West is dealing with a much more severe situation. We are witnessing protests in France, Germany, unemployment is on the rise, while the CIS has work for everybody. If we leave the CIS, where will the great number of our citizens who work in Ukraine and Russia go?,” wonders Krilov.

Valeriu Muravschi: The CIS was created by Russia to dominate the former Soviet republics

Former Prime Minister Valeriu Muravschi said in a recent interview with Radio Free Europe that  Moldova's membership in the CIS has never had a positive effect. „This structure was created by Russia to dominate the former Soviet republics. If in the beginning domination was more geopolitical, we are witnessing economic domination in the last few years,” adds Mr. Muravschi.


Moldova joined the CIS in 1994. From the outset, the country refused to join the Community's military structures. Data show that from 1995 until 2002, Moldova's exports toward the CIS have been on a constant downward slope, dropping by 1.1% per year, even 1.5% when it comes to Russia. In the same period, exports toward the EU have gone up by an average of 1.66% annually. In 1997, 70% of Moldovan exports were going to the CIS. These fell to 52.9% in 2003 and 39.3% in October, 2008. Exports to the European Union amounted to 51.4% in October, 2008.


Nicu Popescu is a researcher with the London-based European Council on Foreign Relations. His areas of expertise include European neighborhood policies, post-Soviet conflicts, relations between the EU and Russia, Moldova, and the South Caucasus. Mr. Popescu is working on a doctorate from the Central European University in Budapest, Hungary. He is fluent in English, French, Russian, and Romanian.

Valeriu Muravschi was Prime Minister of Moldova between May 28, 1991 and July 1, 1992. He was a constant presence in Moldovan politics until he turned to the private sector. Mr. Muravschi was born on July 31, 1949 in the village of Sirato (Orhei). He holds a degree from Chisinau's Sergei Lazo Polytechnical Institute (1971). After graduation, Mr. Muravschi worked as an economist until 1990, when he becomes Minister of Finance in Mircea Druc's cabinet (1990-1991). Valeriu Muravschi was P.M. during the Transnistrian conflict (March-July, 1992). On July 1, 1992, Moldovan President Mircea Snegur replaced him with Andrei Sangheli. According to some rumors at the time, Sangheli's appointment was one of the conditions of the Eltin-Snegur Convention (1992), which required the formation of a „government of conciliation” in Moldova. In 1993, Mr. Muravschi founds the Christian Democratic National Peasants' Party, which he headed until its disappearance in 2002. In 1998, Muravschi was elected on the lists of the “For a Democratic and Prosperous Moldova” Bloc, led by Dumitru Diacov, and served as an M.P. until 2001.

Valentin Krilov has been executive secretary of the Patria-Rodina Socialist Party of Moldova since 1998. He was born on January 12, 1953, in Chisinau. Mr. Krilov is a graduate of the Marine Superior School in Leningrad (now Sankt Petersburg), with a degree in electrical engineering. He served in the Soviet Union Military Navy until 1992. Mr. Krilov was an M.P. from 1990 until 1998, elected on the lists of the Socialist Unity Bloc.

© 2009 Committee for Freedom of the Press

comments powered by Disqus
Home / Opinions & Comments / Can Moldova join the East and the West simultaneously? Nicu Popescu, Valentin Krilov, Valeriu Murasvschi.

Victor Chirila, Moldova – The Falling Star of the Eastern Partnership (EaP), APE/BST, 16.06.2015. 16.06.2015 // 451.926Kb

In the wake of the EaP Summit in Vilnius that took place on 28-29 November 2013, Moldova was considered the brightest star of the EaP. Its merits were evident. It initialed the Association Agreement (AA) including the Deep and Comprehensive Free Trade Aria (DCFTA) with the EU concluded successfully the
APE Policy Paper: The Transnistrian Settlement in Stalemate. APE/FEE. 25.05.2015 25.05.2015 // 329.392Kb

In 2014, the small-step policy of engagement with the Transnistrian administration has stalled. The consultations in the "5+2" format were discontinued and discussions on the political and security issues remained blocked. The sectorial cooperation between both banks has generally known no development. The joint working groups met without deciding anything
Victor Chirila: Towards a new European Neighbourhood Policy: A Moldovan perspective. APE/BST. 25.05.2015. 25.05.2015 // 282.596Kb

Moldova supports the ENP as a general policy framework for its members, nevertheless, it is pledging for a clear cut distinction between ENP’s South and East dimensions, between the Eastern Partnership and the Mediterranean Union, between the European and non-European neighbours of the EU. Moreover, past five year have shown
Read more: Analyses

Interview with Mr. Ion Sturza, ex Prime Minister of the Republic of Moldova: „It is not Putin who is powerful, it is the global leaders who are weak “. 23.03.2014 23.03.2014 // 92.702Kb

Mr. Sturza (53 years old) has started his political carrier in 1999 and became well-known for his nine-month running of the government. Although he withdrew from the political scene, many conationals would be in favor of his presidency in the county across the Prut River (Republic of Moldova – note
Interview with Victor Chirila: Moldova is close to becoming politically and institutionally failed state. Info-Prim Neo. 27.05.2013. 28.05.2013
The Republic of Moldova is very close to becoming a politically and institutionally failed state that will be ignored by its main foreign partners. According to Victor Chirila, executive director of the Foreign Policy Association, the only chance to avoid this collapse is to form a pro-European Government consisting of
Interview with the President of the Republic of Moldova, Nicolae Timofti, to the Lithuanian website 13.07.2012
Nicolae Timofti: I mean a bridge for people, goods and ideas to cross it over. In the Republic of Moldova, we have experts and institutions which are familiar with both East and West. Hundreds of thousands of Moldovans have travelled in Western Europe during the last years and continue to
Read more: Interviews

REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND THE COUNCIL, Fourth Report on the implementation by the Republic of Moldova of the Action Plan on Visa Liberalisation. 21.06.2013. 21.06.2013 // 215.386Kb

Implementation of the European Neighbourhood Policy in 2012 Regional Report: Eastern Partnership, Brussels, 20.3.2013, SWD(2013) 85 final 21.03.2013

Implementation of the European Neighbourhood Policy in Republic of Moldova, Progress in 2012 and recommendations for action, Brussels, 20.3.2013, SWD(2013) 80 final 21.03.2013 // 203.862Kb

Read more: Documents

Frontiers of Democracy:Embedding Democratic Values in Central and Eastern Europe. Good practices and limits of transferability/ CEU/Visegrad Fund/APE. Edited by Bogdan Mihai Radu and Zsuzsanna Végh 02.02.2017
Democratization is a complex process that entails both critical choices of new institutions, and the rooting of those institutions in the societal ethos. Much of the literature on democratic transition, consolidation and Europeanization has been dominated by the study of legal and institutional crafting, especially concerning the post-communist and post-Soviet
Corneiul Ciurea: Confidence-Building in Moldova: Domestic and External Security Challenges. EU/ CIPDD/ APE/ PIC /EaP/ CSF 25.08.2016
Moldova’s security requires a consistent response to home-grown corruption and the risk of resulting political destabilisation along side the risks posed by the Russia Ukraine conflict and information warfare. Confidence-Building in Moldova:Domestic and External Security Challenges assesses the priorities for a security strategy to rebuild trust among citizens and strengthen
Dovilė Šukytė,Victoria Bucătaru,Simonas Čepėnas,Hennadiy Maksak,Svetlana Rogov,Iurii VdovenkoECONOMIC CHALLENGES OF UKRAINE AND MOLDOVA ON THE WAY TO EU. 22.02.2016 // 922.737Kb

The study is a result of the Capacity Building for Moldovan and Ukrainian NGOs to Assess the Economic Impact of Politically Motivated Actions project made possible by the re-granting mechanism of the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum, which includes assistance of the European Union and the National Endowment for Democracy.
Read more: Studies

Weekly Radio Programme 01.02.2009

Read more: Multimedia
str. Sciusev 64, MD-2012 Chisinau, Republica Moldova

Tel.: +373-22-224430, 210986
+373-22-210986, 233950
News  |  Analyses  |  Opinions & Comments  |  Interviews  |  Statements  |  Documents  |  Conferences  |  Studies  |  Events  |  EU - Transnistrian Dialogues  |  Multimedia  |  APE in MassMedia  |  Friedrich Ebert Stiftung  |  Projects  |  European Negociators
Copyright © 2020 Asociaţia pentru Politica Externă din Moldova.
All rights reserved.

This web site was developed and launched with the support of the British Embassy in Moldova
TRIMARAN - IT Solutions Company // web, interactive, motion and software development solutions //, B2B and B2C solutions  /  Branding & Graphic Design Services / Website Design and Development  /  E-Commerce Systems / Software Application Architecture and Development / Multimedia solutions  /  2D/3D modeling & animation solutions / Video & Post Production /
Made in Trimaran
Visits: 510062
Update by: 23.01.2018